Someone cannot qualify on their own. A parent, a sibling or a partner steps in. This is one of the most common ways a purchase gets done, particularly for first-time buyers, and there is nothing wrong with it.
What is worth understanding, before anyone signs, is exactly what the person helping is agreeing to. It is more than most people assume.
The two roles
A co-borrower is on the mortgage and on title. They are an owner of the property. Their income and debts are included in the application and they are fully responsible for the debt.
A guarantor is on the mortgage but not on title. They do not own the property. They guarantee the debt: if the borrower does not pay, the lender comes to them.
Lenders vary in which they will accept and when, and some prefer a co-borrower because the position is cleaner. Which one suits depends on the family, and sometimes on tax considerations, which is why this deserves a conversation with a lawyer or accountant alongside the mortgage conversation.
The part people underestimate
Whichever role, the obligation is for the entire debt. Not a share of it. Not the portion the other person cannot cover.
If payments stop, the lender pursues whoever it can most easily recover from. That is frequently the person with the most assets and the best credit, which is usually the one who stepped in to help.
Three consequences follow, and all of them are easy to miss.
It appears on your credit report as your debt. The full mortgage balance and payment show up against your file. It affects your ratios as though you borrowed the money yourself.
It reduces what you can borrow. If you later want to refinance your own home, buy a property, or take a loan, that mortgage payment is counted against your income. People discover this years later when they are turned down for something and cannot understand why.
Their missed payment is your missed payment. A late payment by the borrower lands on the guarantor’s credit history too. You are relying entirely on someone else’s diligence, and you may not find out until the damage is recorded.
Getting out is difficult
This is the one to think hardest about, because there is no easy exit.
You cannot simply withdraw. Coming off the mortgage requires the lender to release you, and lenders release a guarantor only when the borrower can carry the mortgage alone. In practice that means one of three things: refinancing in the borrower’s name only, qualifying at renewal without you, or selling.
All three require the borrower’s cooperation and their financial readiness. If the relationship has deteriorated in the meantime, which happens, you are tied to a debt with someone who may not be inclined to help you exit it.
Go in assuming it lasts the full amortization, not the first term.
If you are being asked
Ask these before you agree, and ask them out loud rather than politely assuming.
- Could I make these payments if I had to? Not comfortably. At all. If the answer is no, the answer to the request is no, however much you want to help.
- What am I planning in the next few years? A move, a business, a refinance, retirement, helping another child. All of those get harder while this sits on your file.
- Why can they not qualify alone? Thin credit and a short employment history are temporary and resolve on their own. A pattern of missed payments or debts that keep growing is a different situation, and helping may not actually help.
- Is there a plan to remove me? A vague intention is not a plan. A reasonable one names a milestone, such as a refinance once income reaches a level or after a set number of years of clean payment history.
- What happens if the relationship changes? Uncomfortable to raise with family and worth raising anyway. Separation, estrangement and death all complicate this, and the mortgage does not care.
If you are being helped
Understand the size of what you are asking. Someone is putting their credit and, potentially, their savings behind you for years.
A few things make it fairer.
- Pay on time, without exception. Their credit is on the line with yours.
- Keep them informed. If money gets tight, tell them before a payment is missed rather than after.
- Work toward removing them. Treat it as a temporary arrangement with an actual target date.
- Put the arrangement in writing. Who pays what, what happens if you sell, what happens if circumstances change. Between family this feels unnecessary and it is precisely why it is worth doing. A lawyer can prepare something straightforward.
Alternatives worth considering first
Co-signing is not the only route, and sometimes another one fits better.
A gifted down payment. Lenders accept gifts from immediate family with a signed gift letter confirming the money is a gift rather than a loan. A larger down payment can be enough to qualify on its own, and the person helping takes on no ongoing obligation at all. Cleaner for everyone.
Buying together properly. If family are genuinely co-owning rather than supporting, that is a different arrangement with its own agreement setting out shares and what happens on sale.
Waiting. Unromantic and sometimes correct. Six months of building credit, clearing a car loan or saving more can turn a declined application into an approved one without involving anyone else. Our note on what lenders see in your credit covers what moves fastest.
A different lender. Being declined by one lender is not being declined by the market. Lenders treat thin credit, self-employment and newcomer income very differently. Before adding a guarantor, it is worth finding out whether the file simply went to the wrong place. That is most of what a brokerage does.
Before anyone signs
Everyone going on the mortgage should understand the obligation, and the lender will require independent legal advice in some situations anyway. Take it seriously rather than treating it as a formality.
We will set out plainly what each person is taking on, and we will tell you honestly if we think the application would succeed without a guarantor. Send us the situation before anyone commits.
Keep reading
- What lenders see in your creditWhat a co-signer is putting their own file behind.
- The stress test, and why approvals shrinkWhy the gap you are covering exists in the first place.
- Bad credit and alternative lendingWhen a lender matters more than a co-signer.
Questions about your own file?
General guidance only goes so far. Tell us your situation and we will tell you exactly where you stand, with no obligation and no credit check to start.